My friend got me hooked to Sherlock (the one with Benedict Cumberbatch) over Thanksgiving break, and it's high time I review the show. But instead of reviewing the series collectively, I've decided to give a breakdown of my thoughts on each episode.
Credit |
Season 1
Episode 1: A Study in PinkOne of the best lines of the episode (credit) |
- Fun fact: I watched this episode three times in one week: by myself, with my family, and with a family friend to try to get them hooked.
- Super super super good! I love how they explain Sherlock's deductions in a realistic way. He was absolutely mind-blowing in the scene where he first met John Watson.
- Animation/transitions are done super well. Time slows down as Sherlock puts the pieces of the case together, and I really feel like I'm in his head.
- A lot of the episode was watching Sherlock figure everything out. After a while I stopped trying to solve the case, lol.
- The mystery was very intriguing, and so was the killer's motive.
- Overall, 10/10!
- First time I noticed that the intro scenes are done very well! I was dying to know what the museum employee had seen that shocked her.
- Decent mystery, but it was a pretty standard, action-packed story. In fact, it reminded me a lot of the Tintin books (especially when they mention Black Lotus, this is really similar to the The Blue Lotus).
- Overall, 8/10.
Episode 3: The Great Game
Credit |
- First time we meet Moriarty, one of the two major villains of the show!
- I actually did not enjoy the structure of this episode; I liked it better when the episode focused on a large case. Moriarty kept giving Sherlock cases, and he solved them. Because we know Sherlock would solve every case, the episode's repetitiveness got boring fast.
- Killer ending though, no pun intended.
- Overall: 9/10.
Season 2
Episode 1: A Scandal in Belgravia
- This was a lighter episode, a nice break from the seriousness of S1E3.
- I liked that Irene's character was bold and that she was a cunning adversary for Sherlock.
- Irene's fate (the end of the episode) is very funny.
- Overall: 9/10.
Episode 2: The Hounds of Baskerville
Sherlock says he has doesn't have friends, but then John storms away, so he says the above quote. My heart melted (credit). |
- Nice mystery; I was very confused the entire time ;).
- Some parts almost made me jump! I also think Watson is very brave for running into an empty cage when he thought the hound was chasing him; I never would've thought of that personally.
- I have to admit, Sherlock guessing the password to open someone's laptop was too extreme. I don't believe Sherlock is that genius.
- Overall: 9/10.
Episode 3: The Reichenbach Fall
- SO SO SO GOOD. I haven't seen a better season finale for any show, ever.
- I cried at the end, even though I'd read ahead on Netflix and seen what was going to happen in Season 3.
- I really, really liked that Sherlock was stuck and practically hopeless and that he finally takes Molly's help.
- Overall: 11/10. I would definitely rewatch this one!
Season 3
Episode 1: The Empty Hearse
- I love Mary :).
- Best line of the show: "I don't shave for Sherlock." I really want a t-shirt with this on it; it's so catchy.
- Sherlock was very cruel to John, but it was written in such a funny way with all of John's punching, so I couldn't help but feel a little bad for Sherlock.
- We didn't really get to see Sherlock dismantle an entire network of people working for Moriarty, he said everything was done from S2E3 to S3E1. But to be honest, I really just wanted to see him united with John and Mrs. Hudson again, so I guess it's fine ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- Speaking of which, Mrs. Hudson's reaction when she saw Sherlock was the best <3.
Episode 2: The Sign of Three
Credit |
- Such a wholesome episode!
- Sherlock's speech is so sweet!
- This episode is also especially funny. For example, Sherlock shows a kid gruesome pictures and the kid is enamored, and nearly mentions this to his mother.
- Overall: 10/10.
Episode 3: His Last Vow
- WOW Mary is a queen!
Credit |
- Pretty good mystery. It didn't really draw me in as much as some of the others, but it was still fascinating.
- Overall: 9/10.
Special: The Abominable Bride
Credit |
- Creepy
- but also fun!
- Molly honestly looks nice in short hair. I would keep the look.
- I could not fathom this one at all until Sherlock revealed what was going on. Really well done, again!
- Overall: 10/10! Though I probably would not rewatch it just because of how chilling it was.
Season 3 was my favorite season because it was a lot lighter and happier than the rest, which was probably to prepare for the gloomiest season, season 4.
Season 4
Episode 1: The Six Thatchers
Credit |
- Sherlock talking to Rosie is one of the funniest moments of the show.
- Pretty interesting, and it's nice to know what's on that flash drive Mary gave to John. Mary is literally my favorite (after Sherlock and John, ofc ;)).
- BUT THEN THE END CAME AND EVERYTHING WAS VERY VERY VERY BAD. AND I WAS SCARED BECAUSE SHERLOCK AND JOHN WERE BROKEN AND I DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO FIX THEM.
- Overall: 9/10.
Episode 2: The Lying Detective
Credit |
- SO Sherlock was not okay. And John was not okay. Surprisingly Mrs. Hudson seemed to be doing okay, though she was obviously sad.
- Good mystery, though I don't know why Culverton Smith made confessions and erased people's memories on a regular basis; he definitely would have been caught one day anyway.
- Overall: 9/10.
Episode 3: The Final Problem
- I was intrigued by Eurus's high IQ and persuasiveness.
- I was shocked when she revealed that there was no glass between her and Sherlock when he first went to see her.
- Still, the premise of this episode was hard to believe. I found it hard to believe Eurus could control everything on the island she lived on, no matter how high her IQ.
- Also, the show can't keep making people up. First, there's Sherlock's sister. She was never mentioned before, but fine, I understand if you want to add her into the show. But someone new also came in at the end (I want to reveal more but I can't because it's a spoiler). It got ridiculous.
- I can't believe how stupid Mycroft was when he gave Eurus a Christmas present. But he made up for it when he kept insulting John so Sherlock would get angry and shoot Mycroft.
- Not a super satisfying conclusion. I wish we'd gotten to see what happened with Rosie, Molly, Greg, Mrs. Hudson, etc. (besides just a few flashes of everyone hanging out).
- Overall: 9/10.
I normally don't really watch/read mysteries, but this show kept me on my toes the whole time. I was intrigued by Sherlock's deductive ability, and loved how realistically he could deduce things. (Although, obviously, some clues were just written in conveniently, but still.) I also loved the characters: cocky Sherlock, eager Mrs. Hudson, caring John, and cunning Mary. They all go through a lot of character development, especially Sherlock.
This show was super fun and I hope to see similar shows in the future. But maybe I'll wait until after final exams this time ;).
What did you think? Have you watched Sherlock? Have you watched any similar shows to Sherlock? Do you like mysteries? Let me know below!
Credit |
Also, please follow me on bloglovin for quality content ;).